• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

The Wheel or the Computer? Which one has done more for humans?

Without fire, you wouldn't have a graphics metaphor to emphasize how fast your wheel can go, nor a verbal metaphor for how much time and money your computer software project is consuming.

That proves fire is more important than the wheel or the computer.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Myriad said:
Without fire, you wouldn't have a graphics metaphor to emphasize how fast your wheel can go, nor a verbal metaphor for how much time and money your computer software project is consuming.

That proves fire is more important than the wheel or the computer.

Respectfully,
Myriad
Click to expand...

The computer is in its infancy. It won't be a question of who so much as how much.
 
Without computers, you couldn't engage in ridiculous and pointless philosophical arguments with people all over the planet. Therefore... Uh, what was the question again?
 
A portable computer. not a laptop, a big desktop, on wheels.

Both of them win!
 
Bob Blaylock said:
Definitely the wheel. Like most modern things, most really modern forklifts have computers in them to help them to work better; but it is entirely possible to build a forklift without a computer, and most older ones don't have them or need them. But it would be nearly impossible — if not entirely impossible — to build a usable forklift without wheels.
Click to expand...
You heard the man folks, no way to move without wheels.


FYI, I think computers will prove more important in the long run, in this little philosophical masturbation.
 
gdnp said:
In that the computer would have been impossible without the wheel, but the wheel does not rely on computers at all, the wheel wins hands down.
Click to expand...

Jimbo07 said:
Well, in that case, the simple machines win (as argued in one point here, The Lever and the Inclined Plane :D)

Seriously. This isn't a question that can be reasonably asked. The full development of neither computer nor wheel has occurred. Perhaps computers enable the invention of the grogznoxaplorx. What would civilization ever have done without that?
Click to expand...

Myriad said:
Without fire, you wouldn't have a graphics metaphor to emphasize how fast your wheel can go, nor a verbal metaphor for how much time and money your computer software project is consuming.

That proves fire is more important than the wheel or the computer.

Respectfully,
Myriad
Click to expand...


String rules with glue at it's side and fire underneath!

String is KING!

:D

(Look at that string and glue burn, maybe it should be
String rules with glue and fire at it's side, with fire at a safe distance)
 
Last edited:
Rock....First tools. String....Used to tie rocks onto arrow shafts....Glue...used to keep the whole thing from unravelling when you shoot it into a mastodon.

Wheels certainly have longevity, difficult to imagine we could do without them. Even the computer has a few wheels inside. (that is, until solid-state storage becomes the norm, which won't be long.)
Maybe when we start manufacturing with nanotechnology, and operating cars that work with magnetic-lift fields. Likely, kids will still want bicycles.

Still, the computer has helped advance knowledge at an impressive and ever-increasing rate and in a very short time.
 
The wheel has done more for humans. But the computer will do more. There's time, and space, and the predisposition. But the wheel will remain important, as much as the fire.
 
Wait... you need wheels in conveyor belts right? Well without conveyor belts you couldn't run an assembly line which is needed for computer building currently...

As a result, without the wheel, there would be no computer most likely.


INRM
 
The wheel. Definitely. It’s everywhere. And gears, pulleys and motors are just expansions on the wheel concept.

Computers can be used to analyze or control almost anything, but wheels are used to move almost everything.
 
i must say this has proved to be most interesting to observe everyone's thoughts. that in the end, regardless of what people chose, it is easy to see that many people have decided that having one and not the other would be most unpleasant. in my opinion the wheel appears to be winning, yet it's a computer we are debating these thoughts on. is that irony???
 
Faolan said:
i must say this has proved to be most interesting to observe everyone's thoughts. that in the end, regardless of what people chose, it is easy to see that many people have decided that having one and not the other would be most unpleasant. in my opinion the wheel appears to be winning, yet it's a computer we are debating these thoughts on. is that irony???
Click to expand...

ka-ching!
 
Faolan said:
in my opinion the wheel appears to be winning, yet it's a computer we are debating these thoughts on. is that irony???
Click to expand...

Just to reiterate, in my opinion, choosing the wheel is absurd. If you're choosing any of the simple machines, I'd imagine the wedge came first. In fact, the first anything conscripted from its original purpose, like a bone or rock, is probably the single most important invention on the road towards more interesting machines. By the way, simple plows for agriculture have more in common with wedges than wheels.

Moreover we don't know much about the invention of the wheel, but we know an awful lot about the individual players in the invention of electromechanical and electronic computers!
 
Jimbo07 said:
Just to reiterate, in my opinion, choosing the wheel is absurd. If you're choosing any of the simple machines, I'd imagine the wedge came first. In fact, the first anything conscripted from its original purpose, like a bone or rock, is probably the single most important invention on the road towards more interesting machines. By the way, simple plows for agriculture have more in common with wedges than wheels.

Moreover we don't know much about the invention of the wheel, but we know an awful lot about the individual players in the invention of electromechanical and electronic computers!
Click to expand...

yes, but .. the question was wheel or computer... either, or... this or that.... not "which simple machine or more interesting machine has done more for humans"

so, your other opinions aside.. which is it? wheel or computer.. one or the other....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom