As at 2002, the United States allows its citizens to die in the streets without healthcare.
"In 2002, 1,930 people between the ages of 25–34 died due to lack of insurance. From ages 35–44, there were 3,431 deaths due to lack of insurance, and from 45–54, there were 4,734. While a greater number of young people are uninsured, it appears that larger numbers of older adults without insurance may die because they lack it."
(
http://www.dpeaflcio.org/programs/factsheets/fs_2007_health_care_system_intl_perspective.htm)
How would your free-for-all solve this?