• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Pearls of wisdom from an Indigo Child

E-mail from Dr Gowri Motha:

"Thank you for bringing my attention to this matter.

I do know Gary Mannion well as he was introduced to me by Jayn of
splashdown water birth pool hire services who is a very old associate and friend of mine.

As always I maintained an open mind to his talents. I consider him as a
healer in training. I wish him well.

However I have not seen him for a year.

I will ask him to refrain from using my name in his future talks as I was
only investigating his talents at the time that I have known him
."

(my bolding)

More from Dr Motha:

"I consider him as a healer in training.
Perhaps he is yet to surprise us all!
However I do share your concerns about his extravagant claims.
I have yet to be impressed by him.

I consider life as a bit of divine play, and I am vastly amused by it all!"
 
Last edited:
This person (or whoever is writing his tripe) is a slow-witted moron. Do people ever stop?
 
So instead of admitting that they've raised a spoiled brat or an autistic child, the parents claim that their child is the next evolutionary phase.

Pathetic.
"Why not"? Epileptics sometimes was thought to have fortune-telling abilites.
 
After reading a bit of that thread I see that Gary is diagnosing and treating. Are there any laws against that in the UK? He does not seem to claim any "professional" qualifications what-so-ever -- he's not even a Naturopath! :boggled:

Diagnosing and treating you say?

"Oh no you have a horrible internal diseas that your doctor can't detect!"
{waves hands and makes spooky noises}
"There I've cured you. Can I have money now?"
 
"Scentific tests have proven that water stores emotions and memories and when you think of something to move the molecules speed up."
Remind me to use that in some fiction novel or game or whatever. Beautiful if it was true, but of course very disconcerting that she really believes this.
 
Scentific tests have proven that water stores emotions and memories and when you think of something to move the molecules speed up.
I love this one- it would be so easy to test. Pop a thermometer in a glass of water, think -really- hard about the water, and see if the temperature changes.
 
Diagnosing and treating you say?

"Oh no you have a horrible internal diseas that your doctor can't detect!"
{waves hands and makes spooky noises}
"There I've cured you. Can I have money now?"

Don't be silly - the money is paid up front.
 
On the spelling and grammar issue, indigo children are alleged to be more intelligent than we normals. You would think that a 20-year-old with advanced intelligence would have mastered basic English usage. Even if he finds formal education difficult because it stifles his individuality, someone that intelligent should be able to pick up the basics just from reading on his own.
 
Previous speakers in the Alternatives programme at St James' Church include Masaru Emoto, Deepak Chopra and Doreen "Don't forget to mention I'm a PhD" Virtue. Evidently it doesn't matter if you're a scam artist so long as the big Newage names fill the pews.
 
I love Gary Mannions statement "I do not medically claim anything and do not state that what I say is correct."

I'd like to add that last part as a disclaimer to anything that I ever say...
 
So instead of admitting that they've raised a spoiled brat or an autistic child, the parents claim that their child is the next evolutionary phase.

Pathetic.

I posted the following in another thread, addressing it directly to a poster who described himself as an Indigo Child. But it also applies here I think:



Hi shaneasmith. I hesitate to post in this thread, but you have expressed an interest in discussing the topic of Indigo children with skeptics. So I will tell you what I think -- not about you personally, because of course I do not know you, but rather about Indigo children in general.

First, let me say that I do not believe in astral projection, psychic ability, or any of the other paranormal powers it's been claimed Indigo children possess. The reason I don't is very simple: I've never seen any evidence at all that such powers exist. And it's not because I haven't looked, or am closed minded to the possibility -- indeed, I would love to believe that my soul will continue to exist after my body dies, or that I can communicate with others telepathically. Who wouldn't? But every time I examine the evidence for such things, all I ever see are parlor tricks or lucky guesses or special pleading.

Of course, that doesn't mean such powers cannot possibly exist. Paranormal abilities thus far may not be provable, but neither are they disprovable (few if any things are). But it does mean that in order to believe in them, you must do so based on something other than scientific evidence and proof. That may be fine for a lot of people, but my mind simply doesn't work that way.

As for Indigo children, please forgive me if the following comes across as blunt. I don't believe any of them have any special powers at all. Instead, what I fear is happening is that Indigo children for whatever reason feel a strong sense of superiority and entitlement that they simply have not earned. Perhaps this was born with them, perhaps it was created (or at least fed) by constant parental enablement. In any case, a sense of superiority is almost by necessity in search of a reason to exist. For some children, this reason consists of academic or athletic excellence. But those who do not enjoy such "traditional" abilities must look elsewhere to justify their superiority. So (and here comes the part that you might consider unkind) they turn to the one area where their lack of special talent cannot be disproven: the paranormal.

This, I suspect, is why those who call themselves Indigo children seek out others of their own "kind." It's hard to feel superior to children who can perform in the classroom or on the playing field as well as, or better than, you can. But among those who accept unquestioned your self-claimed, unseen, unprovable abilities, you can feel as superior as you want. You can form a sort of mutual admiration society, one in which you can look down on all the "normal" kids whose talents are limited to mundane things such as spelling and athletics and music. It must be a wonderfully supportive environment for someone who might otherwise be rather ordinary and undistinguished among his peers. And with the added bonus of parental support and indulgence, it's easy to see how a child in this situation might feel special indeed.

Well, that's it in a nutshell. Where those who believe in the phenomenon of Indigo children see young people with spectacular abilities that single them out as very special, I see indulged children of no special ability that have constructed around themselves a little fantasy world in which they can feel priviledged. Obviously one of us is probably very wrong. And in all honesty, I would prefer it to be me.
 
A heartfelt apology

I'm so sorry, Alice Shortcake!

I was so irritated by what I read in the OP that I didn't read it carefully enough and thought you were advocating it rather than reporting it.

I immediately posted a message blasting you.

It was a Sweeney Todd moment - I was in a hurry and did badness.

I'm very sorry.
 
A quick update on the Gary front: a spokeswoman for Northwick Park Hospital has informed me that Manesh Naidoo is not Head of Physiotherapy there, and that no-one of that or a similar name has been employed at Northwick Park in the five years she's worked there.

Glen Davies, who according to Gary is a homeopathic doctor with 30 years experience, is not on the registers of the General Medical Council, the British Homeopathic Association, the Homeopathic Medical Association or the Society of Homeopaths.

Still, I'll say this for Indigo Children - they've got lively imaginations...:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom