Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
Seems you lost that bet.
Nah, bogus claims don't cound so let's see what you have?
No, I didn't. You said, "I've got $10 on you hearing crickets," which means there would be
no answer. But Stanfr posted an extensive answer. Just because you claim his answer is "bogus" does not negate the fact he did, indeed, answer.
So, yeah, you did lose that bet.
But how is Trump similar to Hitler? Let me count the ways.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
1. Both had tyrannical and abusive fathers. Hitler was emotionally and physically abused. Trump was emotionally abused.
Srsly?
You'd actually raise that. Brilliant. Half the people in the world are like Hitler.
Yes, Srsly. I listed several "similarities" between them. Having an abusive, tyrannical father IS a similarity between those two particular people. Or are you claiming they did NOT have abusive, tyrannical father in common? Your attempt to equate that to my saying "Half the people in the world are like Hitler," is absurd. But absurdities are often utilized by those who have no other response.
By the way, I never said that having abusive and tyrannical fathers is
why Hitler and Trump are alike." I listed it as one of many similarities. At least be honest enough not to twist what I say to fit your agenda.
There is most certainly a link between an abusive childhood and NPR:
Clarifying the link between childhood abuse history and psychopathic traits in adult criminal offenders
Childhood abuse is a risk factor for the development of externalizing characteristics and disorders, including antisocial personality disorder and psychopathy. However, the precise relationships between particular types of childhood maltreatment and subsequent antisocial and psychopathic traits remain unclear. Using a large sample of incarcerated adult male criminal offenders (n = 183), the current study confirmed that severity of overall childhood maltreatment was linked to severity of both psychopathy and antisocial personality disorder in adulthood.
Moreover, this relationship was particularly strong for physical abuse and the antisocial facet of psychopathy.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
2. Hitler believed himself superior and destined to rule Germany. Trump believes himself superior and the only one who can "save American".
Like every other politician who's ever lived. As it happens, I don't believe Trump thinks that at all, whereas Dear Adolph definitely did. I think Trump is an insecure blowhard. Hitler didn't lie about his height that I'm aware of.
When you have to resort to such hyperbolic nonsense as claiming that "
every politician who ever lived" believes they are superior, destined to rule and only they can save their country, it only weakens your position.
Of course, Trump is an insecure blowhard, but that is a characteristic of NPD!
Maybe do a little research before opining on something.
Surely you have better...
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
3. Hitler held rallies in which his adoring followers worshipped him. Trump holds rallies in which his adoring followers worship him, many believing he was sent by God.
Not yet...
Wow, that's some counter argument! Real
National Debate Tournament quality!
Hey you found one!
That 1-3 so far.
I've supported everything I've said. Have you given a single rebuttal other than sarcastic quips? Not yet. Surely you can do better....
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
5. Hitler on several occasions used the phrase "make Germany great again" Trump (falsely) claimed he invented MAGA...Make American Great Again.
Nah, old news. Winston Peters was on that track in the 1990s. Trump knowing Hitler said it would imply he reads and we both know that isn't the case.
1-4
So, being "old news" does not make it any less true. As usual, the point goes right over your head.
They were preaching the same message: our country is not respected, it's falling apart and we need to make it like it used to be: GREAT!"
Hitler was a politician of the will, full of grandiose commitments and few detailed policies. His core was a commitment to make Germany great again, in the parlance of our day, to "take back his country". Detailed policy of how this would happen was rarely expounded even where it existed.
Hitler called it the Third Reich (Empire) because he saw it as the natural successor to the first German Holy Roman Empire and the second German empire under the Hapsburgs. In other words: Make Germany great again.
Trump on the 2016 campaign trail: “the world is laughing at us.”
Trump on the 2020 campaign trail: "You know, we're respected again. You may not feel it, although I think you do. You may not see it. You don't read about it from the fake news, but this country is respected again."
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
6. Hitler took control of the newspapers through various methods giving control to the Nazi Party. Trump attacks the news media calling them "Fake News" so no one will believe them when they write negative stories about him.
Utter bollocks.
HuffPo, NYT, WaPo and many other outlets are as insanely anti-Trump as Fox et al are pro. Trump does not control the media.
1-5
Try reading for comprehension.
I never said Trump controls the media. Once again, the point goes right past you. The point is that Hitler took control of the media so he could control what they said about him and what the German people could be led to believe.
Trump does not have the power to control what
all the media says, but conservative media obsequiously panders to him. They only print/say positive things about him and either ignore or downplay anything negative about him that cannot be ignored. Trump admitted he uses the term 'fake news' to spread distrust of the media so people won't believe any negative reports about him. MAGA live in a pro-Trump bubble, getting their info from Truth Social which is nothing but a lie-a-thon, Fox, OAN, Newsmax and right-wing radio.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
7. Hitler used bullying rhetoric. Trump uses bullying rhetoric often to intimidate his opponents.
That's gold! Right after berating me for my attack on Hillary you are absolutely equating the Brownshirts and Gestapo with Trump saying mean things.
This is a lot more fun than I expected.
1-6
Seriously, dude; do you have a reading comprehension problem?
Apparently, you don't know what "rhetoric" means: it's
"the use of persuasive language".
The Brownshirts and Gestapo were not
"rhetoric". The Brownshirts were para-military thugs who beat up and killed people. The Gestapo was the secret police.
But thanks for admitting you were 'attacking' Hillary. And your weird interpretation of what she said is just further evidence that you may have a reading comprehension problem.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
8. Hitler lied as easily as he breathed. Trump is a pathological liar.
My mum always told me that only one bloke never lied, and since she said his name was Jesus and I think he didn't exist I'm happy to say the man who never lied hasn't been born yet.
Did Hillary lie about Benghazi?
1-7
Do you really need to have explained to you the difference between what I said and your off-the-wall comparison fallacy? Apparently, you do:
Everyone lies, I didn't say otherwise.
But not everyone who lies is a pathological liar.
"Pathological lying is a compulsive pattern of telling untruths that may be related to or
caused by mental health conditions or trauma."
"Pathological lying is a sign of some mental health conditions, especially personality disorders.
People with certain conditions —
including narcissistic personality disorder and antisocial personality disorder — tend to act in manipulative or deceitful ways regardless of the consequences and upset it might cause.
Again with Hillary Clinton who has nothing to do with the similarities between Hitler and Trump. The more you post, the more I think your interpretation of what she said has more to do with WHO said it rather than WHAT she said.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
9. Psychologists/psychiatrists who have never met Trump have studied them and believe they had/have Narcissistic Personality Disorder, including paranoia.
FTFY
1-8
Ah...falling back on the old "But the Barry Goldwater Rule!" excuse. When someone has their femur sticking up through their skin after hitting a tree, a doctor doesn't have to see them in person to say "Hey, you've got a compound fracture of the femur!"
Mary [Trump], a clinical psychologist, said her uncle failed to develop human emotion because his father created an abusive and traumatic home life.
There are
decades of Trump interviews, speeches, articles, and interviews from those who personally interacted with him for years, etc. There's far more information about him from those than sitting down with him for an hour in person.
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
No, Trump is not Hitler and no one knows if he would become as bad as Hitler.
Nice of you to spend all that time losing an argument only to admit you have no idea what you're talking about at the end.
I strongly suggest a course in reading comprehension as this is one of several things you
think I've said when I haven't. Really, the only thing you've done is to make snarky and irrelevant retorts with no facts disproving a thing I've said yet you think
I'VE lost this argument?
