• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more
Despite several scientific studies and numerous government investigations, the debate around what’s making people sick still hasn’t been fully resolved. Could the job these foreign-service and intelligence officers do — trying to keep America safe — in outposts like Cuba and Russia and China be so stressful that it causes serious neurological symptoms? And is Havana Syndrome still a national security threat — since it’s taking out some of the best and brightest Americans in the foreign service and intelligence?
What Should the U.S. Do About Havana Syndrome? (New America, May 30, 2023)


The debate will never be resolved. The alleged mystery was resolved years ago.

I haven't yet read the full article or listened to the podcast, but I guess I may have to in order to find out why the author cherry picks outposts like Cuba, Russia and China. Why don't Washington, London, Berlin, Paris, Geneva and Vienna qualify to be on his list? The latter, Vienna, has been mentioned as the U.S. embassy with the most 'syndrome' victims outside of Havana!

And are the 'Havana syndrome' sufferers really the best and the brightest Americans in the foreign service and intelligence? I ask because I've never heard of any of them before. I can see why I wouldn't have heard about people in intelligence agencies, but among embassy workers I haven't heard about any ambassadors being victims of the 'syndrome', but maybe they are not the best and brightest.
 
In Pop Culture

finally, the swifties have their own version of Havana Syndrome
Séamus Malekafzali (Twitter, June 1, 2023)
These days fans are treated to mind-blowing spectacles, with strobe lights, massive props and more costume changes than you can keep track of - so it's no surprise you are not going to remember everything you have experienced after having to process so much.
Anushka Sri watched Suga from Korean K-pop's BTS perform in Los Angeles on 11 May.
She says most concerts she goes to have "elements of surprise all the time" as well as intensive light movement and fireworks which she thinks "kind of causes memory loss".
Taylor Swift fans report 'amnesia' following Eras show (BBC, June 1, 2023)


The Pokémon MPI in Japan was believed to have been "triggered by sudden anxiety after dramatic mass media reports describing a relatively small number of genuine photosensitive-epilepsy seizures." (Pokémon Contagion. Photosensitive Epilepsy or Mass Psychogenic Illness? (Bioteach.ubc.ca/Southern Medical Journal, Feb 2001))
However, in the case of MPI caused by Taylor Swift, whose songs I somehow don't remember ever hearing, Dr Helen Prior of has good news:
Dr Helen Prior, senior lecturer at the University of Hull, is interested to see whether some of the memories and emotions Taylor Swift's fans have forgotten can be recalled when they listen to her songs at a later date.
Whether it's listening to your first wedding song or playing your break-up anthem on repeat, music is an art form that has the power to transform you back to a particular time in your life.
So for Swifties worried about having forgotten bits of the show, listening to the set list again might just make all those memories come flooding back.


I assume it may even help 'syndrome' victims if they play the cricket tapes again, over and over, and keep reminding themselves that there was no reason to be scared, that 'It was just crickets, just crickets. There was no attack, nobody was harmed by the sound, it was just crickets, just crickets ...'
 
It is sometimes interesting to go back and watch what was said in the case of 'Havana Syndrome' months and years ago.
A link to this NBC News video just popped up again when I was doing a Google search:
This appears to be the exact same video as the one attached to the NBC News article mentioned in post 1168, Legal, financial fights mount as 'Havana Syndrome' goes unsolved (NBC News, Dec 22, 2021), in case any of you couldn't access it:
Fighting An Invisible Enemy: The Voices Of Havana Syndrome


6:36 --> 7:22:
Cheryl Cruise: I think at the very beginning, it was very hush-hush. Something is going on that the department doesn't know what it is, and we just need to be careful.
NBC speaker (?): People started to raise the possibility that this was psychosomatic, that it was mass psychogenic illness.
Cheryl Cruise: Several of us went to the security office. We listened to the sound that they had recorded. I'm like, 'Wow, that's the sound I heard'. Then they were pretty much, 'No', you know, 'You're wrong. You didn't hear that.'
So that was the start of trying to figure out how to get people to believe me.


The irony is that nowadays (i.e. at least since September 2022), their own lawyer, Mark Zaid, is telling them to forget about the bloody cricket sound!:
Zaid: They really did hear those sounds because they really did hear crickets, you know, at the time something was happening to them. But the crickets have nothing to do with, you know, whatever this is. Unless of course, I guess, some country got so advanced that they attached some sort of weapon to distract them with crickets, like passenger crickets or something, right, in a game where pigeons were actually used, were designed to be used ...
Interviewer: When you say it was unfortunate, you are talking about the recording of ...
Zaid: The recording! The recording has nothing to do with what these incidents are! It was total coincidence that at a point in time where whatever number of people recorded things, one or two, I guess, that, whatever they were experiencing, they happened to also hear crickets. And then they turned their phone on or something.
From post 1,602.

I wonder if anybody actually tried to convince Cheryl Cruise that she didn't hear the sound. I think it's more likely that they told her that they didn't think she had been attacked, which to her, at the time, may have been interpreted as being synonymous with refusing to believe in the one thing that to her proved that she had been attacked.

I don't think Cheryl Cruise has said anything publicly about the 'syndrome' since December 2021. The CIA interim report was published in January 2022.

I guess a recording of those sessions at the security office, if such recordings exist, probably won't be available to the general public even though they should be.
The Freedom of Information Act?
 
... I haven't yet read the full article or listened to the podcast, but I guess I may have to in order to find out why the author cherry picks outposts like Cuba, Russia and China. ...
It appears to require a subscription to Audible.
 
Short but damning:
In their requiem to the so-called Havana syndrome, Bartholomew and Baloh list five factors that contributed to its creation. I will elaborate on one of them, namely that this novel entity was forged with unreliable data.
(...)
The anguish and debilitation lamented by all those who suffer from these symptoms, should be taken very seriously, and addressed consequently. However, rather than postulating a questionable new syndrome, it would prove advisable to conform to the prescription of parsimony (Danek et al., 2022) and analyse the data for what they can reveal. Abiding with the pressure of taming the data to the demand of politicians, granting them undue authority in
their stance (Krylov, 2021), contradicts the very essence of scientific endeavour (Popper,
1994). I am not arguing the science should be naively apolitical or that data should be exempt from political interpretation (see Ball, 2021); rather I maintain that scientists should aim at collecting sound data with impeccable methods, not piloted by a priori political frames. Had we done so, the Havana syndrome would have never appeared.
Politics dictating on science is like a gunshot in a concert: Commentary to “Havana Syndrome: A Post Mortem”, by Robert E. Bartholomew and Robert W. Baloh (Sergio Della Sala, Edinburgh Neuroscience, University of Edinburgh)


Unfortunately, I can't find the article by Baloh and Bartholomew, Politics dictating on science is like a gunshot in a concert: Commentary to “Havana Syndrome: A Post Mortem”, that Della Sala's article is a commentary to.

The title appears to be an allusion to this quotation:
"Politics in a literary work, is like a gun shot in the middle of a concert, something vulgar, and however, something which is impossible to ignore.” (Stendhal)
 
Short video clip:

Judy Woodruff and Nick Schifrin discuss the debilitating medical ailments affecting U.S. diplomatic and intelligence officers in Cuba — which have become known as Havana Syndrome. Six months in, what steps has the Biden administration taken to aid those affected?
CIA still investigating U.S. diplomats' 'Havana Syndrome' (PBS Newshour, WETA.org, May 29, 2023 - 3:18)


At the beginning of the clip, they mention that there have been hundreds of cases, yet they don't say that the vast majority of those cases have actually been explained, that the causes (not the cause) have been found. Instead, they pretend that everything is still an open question as if the ODNI report from Mar 1, 2023 never happened. They even manage to find a sound bite where Blinken seems to be as unaware of the ODNI report as they pretend to be:

1:33-->
- So are they any closer to figuring out the cause?
- In a word, no. They don't know who or what or if anyone set out to target U.S. officials.
There was a panel of medical experts last year that concluded that it could, could have been microwave radiation. And that panel of experts pointed out that the Russians have researched using microwave radiation in the past. But senior administration officials still say they do not know if this is a foreign actor's actions or perhaps some kind of inadvertent side effect of overly aggressive surveillance or something else.
And partially, it's a range of apparent victims. Intelligence agents who work on Russia say they've had these symptoms, diplomats working in Europe. Even a White House official late last year. And after that incident, there was a deputies meeting at the National Security Council,
and they decided they simply did not have enough evidence to know what was really going on. And that conclusion remains today.
Take a quick listen to Secretary of State Tony Blinken last month.

Blinken: We do not know who, if anyone, is actually responsible, state actor or individuals.
This is exactly what we are trying to get to the bottom of.

- Blinken's 'who, if anyone,' angered a lot of people in Congress. Look, there are still doubts about the cause, but this administration says they're focussing more resources to help the apparent victims and try to find the cause.


So even though cases were explained in the vast majority of cases and not the tiniest bit of evidence pointed at a foreign adversary, they hang on the idea that just such an adversary might still somehow be responsible even though nothing makes it plausible that any adversary or any raygun ever harmed an American.
It's dishonest as hell, but it serves to fuel the anger of people against the fictitious (and yet very real albeit fictitious) perpetrator who is somehow responsible for harming U.S. spies and embassy staff.
Let's keep the hate alive, folks.

However, one thing makes me wonder: "Six months in"
Could this be an old clip that they just pretend is new? Is it from July 2021 and not from May 2023? It would explain why they talk about hundreds of cases instead of more than 1,000.
On the other hand, they appear to be referring to the only recently released Expert Panel's report which was from 2022, so probably not ...
 
I got this wrong:
Unfortunately, I can't find the article by Baloh and Bartholomew, Politics dictating on science is like a gunshot in a concert: Commentary to “Havana Syndrome: A Post Mortem”, that Della Sala's article is a commentary to. (Stendhal)


The title of the article by Baloh and Bartholomew would have been "Havana Syndrome: A Post Mortem", whereas "Politics dictating on science is like a gunshot in a concert" would be the title of Della Sala's commentary.

However, that doesn't help much because a search for "Havana Syndrome: A Post Mortem" only comes up with links to Sergio Della Sala's commentary.

Did he confuse it with this Bartholomew article (mentioned in post 1,789)? The Death of Havana Syndrome (2016-2023): R.I.P. (Skeptic, March 13, 2023)
 
Alien Attack? Mass Hysteria? Conspiracy?

Garry Nolan again (see post 1,916):

Dr Garry Nolan, a well-known immunologist and professor at Stanford University, and a Nobel Prize nominee, made a bold claim at a recent conference in Manhattan, claiming that there is an absolute certainty, a "100 per cent," that extraterrestrial life forms have visited Earth in the past and continue to be present on our planet today.
(...)
Nolan also reported his engagement with the CIA, where he used his immunology skills to research medical difficulties supposedly caused by contact with mysterious aerial phenomena.
He emphasised the striking similarities between the symptoms displayed by these patients and the ailment known as "Havana syndrome," which was originally identified in Cuba in 2016 and affected numerous US officials and military personnel stationed abroad.
Do aliens live among us? Famous immunologist, Nobel Prize nominee claims they do (WION, June 2, 2023)


It's far from the first time that Nobel Prize nominees or even actual winners have gone rogue.
 
Perhaps as a symptom of America’s broader imperial decline, the CIA seems to be undergoing an identity crisis. Officers have given press interviews describing their struggles with mental health, which a more frank analysis might identify as a repressed but justified sense of guilt regarding their chosen profession.35 Bizarre sideshows like the recent panic over “Havana Syndrome”—wherein agents reported concussion-like symptoms supposedly caused by directed energy weapons—elicited journalistic coddling and pledges of government subsidy of victims’ medical bills, even as the agency’s own experts seem to have debunked the phenomenon altogether.36Lie, cheat, and steal: The CIA’s disastrous scientific legacy (MRonline.org, June 6, 2023)


Interesting idea, but I very much doubt that the 'syndrome' is the sudden onset of a repressed bad conscience.
 
Without people's agendas, the 'syndrome' would never have come to the attention of people outside of the U.S. embassy in Havana. Patient Zero deliberately spread the idea to other U.S. officials as well as to his Canadian neighbors, the Trump administration used it to break off diplomatic relations with Cuba (again!) and exacerbate the blockade, U.S. warmongers used it to claim that Russians were wrecking the brains of Americans and to call for retaliation, and Targeted Individuals latched on to the idea to make their own persecution mania look plausible. Even after the ODNI report stated that there was no sign of any there there, they all still cling to the idea because it's so useful.

If there were no 'Havana syndrome', they would have to invent it.
In fact, they did!
 
Houston TI meeting - Saturday, 8 April 2023, 9am - 11am Onion Creek, 3106 White Oak Dr, ... #1 Website for Targeted Individuals and Havana Syndrome.
Gang Stocking (standout.de, April 8, 2023)


I blame English pronunciation! :)
Safari warns me against visiting the site, so I don't post the actual link.
 
I mentioned Ragini Verma, a professor of radiology at the University of Pennsylvania, in post 1,817, where I also quoted her (or rather: quoted an article with a quotation from her).
She now appears to have offended TI Len Ber, but I can't find the tweet that his tweet is supposed to be a response to:

@Ragini__Verma
I found it condescending that you didn’t reply to my multiple emails and phone calls with with respect to UPenn #HavanaSyndrome study, but decided to follow me out of “morbid curiosity”. Is there a name for this creepy behavior?
Len Ber MD (Twitter, Jun 9, 2023)


I suspect that she may not be the only one.
 
New podcast by Tim Harford, “the Undercover Economist”:

CIA agents in Havana complaining of mental fog, dizziness, ear pain in 2016. Children in Miami in 1974, hyperventilating and wracked with abdominal pain. A medieval outbreak of the “dancing plague”. A chorus of meowing nuns.
These mysterious events may have a single, simple explanation — one that’s often overlooked when it comes to understanding strange new syndromes.
Sonic Poison? The genesis of Havana syndrome (Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford, June 9, 2023 - 37:04 min.)


The podcast is more about mass psychogenic illness (MPI) in general than about the 'Havana syndrome' in particular. In fact, we hear more about the Miami case in 1974 than about the U.S. embassy cases, but it is a well-chosen case for illustrating what MPI is about and for describing the difficulty doctors are face with when they have to find out if an illness is psychogenic of physiogenic.
 
A US$28 million renovation project now underway is a little-known but critical investment in U.S. diplomacy on the island, which has also included an increase in consular staff and programs to "advance human rights" and private business in the communist-run country.
(...)
But the project also underscores the still rocky relationship between Cuba and the U.S., which flared again earlier this week on a U.S. media report* that China had reached a secret deal with Cuba to establish a spy base on the island aimed at the United States.**
U.S. officials immediately cast doubt on report, and Cuba on Thursday denied it outright. But the Cuban government also seized the opportunity to accuse the U.S. of being behind a fabrication meant to justify Washington's decades-old economic embargo against the island.
(...)
The building, which operated for years as the "U.S. Interests Section," reopened as an embassy in July 2015 when diplomatic relations were restored under Barack Obama. But its staffing was cut sharply two years later after U.S. personnel began to report a mysterious ailment dubbed "Havana Syndrome."
U.S. intelligence investigations have since determined it "very unlikely" a foreign adversary was responsible for the illness, and a more robust staff and agenda have returned to Havana, Ziff said.
US gives Havana embassy a facelift after years of neglect (Today Online, June 10, 2023)


*China seeking to spy on the U.S. from a base in Cuba (Politico, June 8, 2023)
**Cuba denies existence of Chinese military base on the island (Granma.cu, June 9, 2023)
**China demands US to stop interfering and defaming Cuba (Prensa Latina, June 10, 2023)

This is just one new addition to the long legacy of lies that the United States has been spinning in an attempt to further alienate the Cuban people. One just has to remember the “Havana syndrome” that mysteriously affected diplomats in Cuba; it was first blamed on foreign powers as an attack but was later revealed to have no basis. Or maybe the claims about 20,000 Cuban soldiers supposedly based in Venezuela to maintain the government there, when in reality, the vast majority of Cubans present in Venezuela were medical workers. Or perhaps the idea that Cuban doctors sent across the world are enslaved, when it is simply their understanding that their duty to humanity is to provide health care to those who need it. All of these lies have been told just in the past few years alone.

These falsified stories all swirl into fomenting the atmosphere of paranoia and suspicion that prevents normal US-Cuba relations. In the wake of the Havana syndrome myth, Trump was able to interrupt the path Obama set toward normalization, setting 243 additional and comprehensive sanctions, and further preventing the island from meeting its basic needs. The United States continues to live out its Cold War fantasies through these lies, at the cost of the Cuban people’s lives and well-being.
US tells another bedtime story to scare away normal relations with China and Cuba (People's Dispatch, June 9, 2023)
 
Last edited:
Long, weird Twitter thread:
DEEP DIVE: HAVANA SYNDROME - CRIMSON MIST - THE VOICE OF GOD - AND THE EVIDENCE SHOWING EM RADIATION CAN MANIPULATE AND/OR DESTROY YOUR MIND (TWEET 1/12)
Sense Receptor (Twtter, June 9, 2023)


The main witness for the defense (of the DEW attack idea), "the late American physicist and parapsychologist Elizabeth A. Rauscher," doesn't manage to convince me that the 'syndrome' is caused by directed energy weapons. She may have been a physicist conducting "research into the effects of electromagnetic fields on brain waves," but her superstitious ideas make me skeptical of her other claims:
Rauscher has an interest in psychic healing and faith healing.
Kaiser describes how Rauscher's personal interests within the group lay with remote viewing, precognition, psychokinesis, remote healing, and ghosts. Jeffrey John Kripal writes that Rauscher broadened the group to include non-physicists, and in the late 1970s and early 1980s the group's members met annually at the Esalen Institute to continue their exchange of ideas, exerting a major influence on alternative religious thought in the United States.
Elizabeth Rauscher: Parapsychology (Wikipedia)


It also doesn't help convince me when the rage of the Hutus and Tutsis in Rwanda three decades ago is claimed to (maybe) have been augmented electronically by the "deployment of a plane-mounted microwave dish":
Even though it's difficult to find even a single official source describing "Operation Crimson Mist," if it was a real mission that really was executed by the U.S. Intelligence Community (IC), then it likely stands as the most dastardly and horrifying example of how EM radiation can be used to an insidious end, as it heavily exacerbated the Rwandan genocide.

Although the conventional narrative surrounding "the worst outbreak of violence ever recorded on the African continent" focuses on an extensive history of antagonism between the Tutsi and Hutu ethnic groups as the driver of the genocide—along with the mass sale of weapons to Rwandan Tutsi exiles known as the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF) by the U.S. and inadequate action by the U.S. and other UN nations to head off the conflict—there is speculation that it was actually catalyzed (in effect) by the deployment of a plane-mounted microwave dish that “electromagnetically augmented" the ethnic groups' pre-existing state of "rage."
It seems the most widely referenced source of the "Crimson Mist" story was written by the late Joe Vialls, a mysterious Australian journalist and "conspiracy theorist" who authored the book Deadly Deception at Port Arthur. Vialls, who claimed to be a combat veteran wrote in a post published on May 29, 2003 that the "US Intelligence" community used a C-130 Hercules carrying a microwave dish to generate the "precise 'control' brain wave" for rage, which they then beamed down upon the Hutu and Tutsi with the goal of "augmenting and thus upgrading crowd behavior from that of angry demonstrators to uncontrollable genocidal maniacs."


I don't recognize this particular symptom from the stories told by the 'syndrome' sufferers.
 
Last edited:
Kudos to professor Kevin Fu, who is able to say that he was wrong! (I don't use the word admit. It's not a sin, a crime, admission of guilt or shameful in any way to find out that you were wrong and say so.)

Kevin Fu, an electrical and computer engineering professor at Northeastern University, says the real cause is probably something simpler: crickets.
“The greatest contender right now is the short-tailed West Indies cricket, which has a chirp that’s extremely annoying to the point where it can cause harm to you,” Fu says. “That’s the theory I’d put my money on, but it’s still unsolved. In my opinion, it’s not likely it’s a nation state trying to deliberately cause harm.”
With his experience in the “dark arts of electronic warfare,” Fu appeared on the most recent episode of History Channel’s “History’s Greatest Mysteries” focused on Havana syndrome. In 2018, Fu performed experiments with ultrasound that showed how Havana syndrome could be the result of “malfunctioning ultrasonic eavesdropping devices.”
But since that time, Fu has come around to the cricket theory––and he’s not alone. In a declassified report, JASON, an advisory group that works with the State Department, also found reason to believe that the Indies short-tailed cricket could be the culprit. The group performed a pulse repetition analysis of audio captured in Cuba and audio of these crickets and found they were remarkably similar.
The chance of that being randomly the same is zero,” says Fu, who was recently appointed to the White House’s working group on cybersecurity resilience.
“That was convincing enough, but then on top of that, it’s a really simple explanation,” Fu continues. “It explains all the symptoms, whereas all the other approaches really require a healthy dose of imagination.”
What’s the real cause of Havana Syndrome? Northeastern professor explains on ‘History’s Greatest Mysteries’ (Northeastern Global News, June 13, 2023)


I wonder why the article still claims that "The real cause of Havana syndrome remains a mystery", but I guess it couldn't be on an episode of History's Greatest Mysteries if it weren't! :)

The new episode on History Channel, The Mysterious Havana Syndrome, Season 4, Episode 18, was aired yesterday, Monday June 12, 2023.
In 2016 a mysterious illness strikes dozens of government officials in Cuba. Over the next few years, hundreds more are afflicted. But investigations raise more questions than answers about this bizarre epidemic. What is the true cause of the strange phenomenon known as "Havana Syndrome?"
https://next-episode.net/historys-greatest-mysteries


History Channel's teaser on Twitter:
Starting in 2016, a mysterious illness afflicted hundreds in Cuba, with no known cause, seemingly traced back to a bizarre, irritating sound. What is Havana Syndrome? #HistorysGreatestMysteries examines the situation on an all-new episode, tonight at 9/8c.
History (Twitter, June 12, 2023 - 1:49 min.)


Targeted Individuals are already up in arms:
Darpa Neuroscientist explains #NeuroWeapons aka #HavanaSyndrome
https://youtu.be/8Wu89LXTmWs
It's been used on ALL of you��
#TargetedIndividuals (Twitter, June 13, 2023)
 
Last edited:
I don't know if Targeted Individual Len Ber is aware of History Channel's new episode (see post above). Robert Kennedy Jr has already disappointed him. He seems to think that backing up the claims of TIs is a step too far:

Tell the #truth. That’s a pretty ballsy slogan. Will you tell the truth about #TargetedIndividuals and stop this atrocious program? Or will you find some excuse like “these allegations are too fantastical to believe”. But truth is not about belief. I would really like to know which definition of truth you are using, @RobertKennedyJr
Len Ber MD (Twitter, June 12, 2023)


And another disappointment: Len Ber thought that he had found the thing that would make all skepticism go away, This will erase the rest of your comfy skepticism about the Targeted Individual Program (Len Ber MD on Substack, June 13, 2023), but in the meantime Targeted Justice, Inc, has become skeptical of the source of the article:
Until we are able to firmly determine the authenticity and source of the information, we are withdrawing this news article.
Thanks for your patience and support.
News article withdrawn... (Targeted Justice, Inc, on Substack, June 13, 2023)
 
Chinese Xinhua has fact-checked seven U.S. claims about Cuba since the 1960s.
The most recent claim is the one about a new Chinese spy base against the USA (see post 1,935), but it not one of the seven.

#4 is the 'Havana syndrome':
The following lies touted by the U.S. administration about Cuba disclosed its purpose of discrediting the socialist movement and achievements of the Cuban government and its people.
(...)
4. False: The Trump administration repeatedly denounced that Cuba carried out "sonic attacks" on U.S. diplomatic personnel and caused them to suffer "Havana Syndrome." Such claim has led to a further deterioration of bilateral relations.
True: Cuba has always adhered to the Vienna Convention and has never perpetrated attacks of any kind against diplomatic personnel from any country, nor has it allowed its territory to be used for such purposes. Scientific evidence has demonstrated that the Cuban territory was not used for sonic attacks against U.S. diplomats.
Meanwhile, Cuban diplomats have fallen victim to acts of violence in the United States orchestrated by members of well-known terrorist groups with links to Washington.
Fact check of U.S. lies against Cuba (English.News.cn, June 13, 2023)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom