If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong. Part II

[Myriad]

Does the Cookie Monster have a digestive system? No. That might be the reason he is not used for nutrition studies.

Your example does not apply to Cole's experiments.

Cole's experiments puppet show doesn't have a digestive system either, but it still manages to be full of ****.

 

[FalseFlag]

Cole's experiments puppet show doesn't have a digestive system either, but it still manages to be full of ****.

Your statement isn't correct, but it is amusing. +1

 

[Belz...]

You're statement isn't correct, but it is amusing. +1

*Your

 

[Myriad]

You're statement isn't correct, but it is amusing. +1

My statement is correct. "Replicating the motion" is indicative only of a well-conducted puppet show. More is needed for a meaningful applicable experimental result.

Herpetologists don't study Kermit the Frog. Family court judges don't incarcerate Punch and Judy. Forensic structural engineers disregard Cole's video.

 

[FalseFlag]

*Your

Thanks.

 

[FalseFlag]

Forensic structural engineers disregard Cole's video.

Perhaps you could prove this claim by providing a link to a credible source that shows this is true.

 

[DGM]

Perhaps you could prove this claim by providing a link to a credible source that shows this is true.

Maybe you could show a link to a credible group that supports his view?

It is your claim that this video has merit.

 

[Myriad]

Perhaps you could prove this claim by providing a link to a credible source that shows this is true.

Sure, here you go.

The distinct lack of reports of structural engineers reacting to Cole's video is unmistakable.

 

[MileHighMadness]

Perhaps you could prove this claim by providing a link to a credible source that shows this is true.

Real, licensed structural engineers write papers on their experiments, and submit them to the ASCE Structural Journal for publication and peer review. Idiots post videos on YouTube.

 

[Dave Rogers]

Herpetologists don't study Kermit the Frog. Family court judges don't incarcerate Punch and Judy.

Perhaps you could prove this claim by providing a link to a credible source that shows this is true.

Dave

 

[HotRodDeluxe]

And the chain yanking continues....

 

[Crazy Chainsaw]

Real, licensed structural engineers write papers on their experiments, and submit them to the ASCE Structural Journal for publication and peer review. Idiots post videos on YouTube.

Yes and the papers they write are full of math, giving a mathematically correct model.

 

[FalseFlag]

Real, licensed structural engineers write papers on their experiments, and submit them to the ASCE Structural Journal for publication and peer review. Idiots post videos on YouTube.

OK. Can you provide a link to a report or experiment performed by a real, licensed, structural engineer that supports NIST's findings? If you can find one, please make sure to include all of the peer reviews. Thanks.

 

[FalseFlag]

Sure, here you go.

The distinct lack of reports of structural engineers reacting to Cole's video is unmistakable.

1. How many structural engineers have seen it?
2. Why would they respond to it if they agree with it?

 

[jsfisher]

OK. Can you provide a link to a report or experiment performed by a real, licensed, structural engineer that supports NIST's findings? If you can find one, please make sure to include all of the peer reviews. Thanks.

You are not up on how peer review works, are you.

 

[FalseFlag]

You are not up on how peer review works, are you.

OK.
Please post peer reviews of NIST's reports.
Is that what I should have asked?

 

[DGM]

OK. Can you provide a link to a report or experiment performed by a real, licensed, structural engineer that supports NIST's findings? If you can find one, please make sure to include all of the peer reviews. Thanks.

Can you post a review from a respected professional that supports your view? I'll wait.

 

[jsfisher]

OK.
Please post peer reviews of NIST's reports.
Is that what I should have asked?

No. It was not your phrasing that was at issue; it was your general (lack of) understanding of the peer review process.

 

[Axxman300]

I am not an expert, so I do not have an answer.

The answer is yes.

 

[pgimeno]

Read my whole post.

LOL.